Farewell Feast: Chef Jay’s Secret Supper Club Bids Orlando Goodbye
Secret pop-up dinner clubs still have bite in Central Florida, but we are saying goodbye to a phenomenal one by Chef Jay.
His Christmas dinner in December will be the last hurrah of a monthly feast for those in the know — the kind of people who find out about elegant dinner parties and wild raves through an algorithm seeking them out. However, for the final Dinner With Strangers series, just this once, I think he deserves to have the world know his secret.
For Thanksgiving dinner, his usual opulence was reduced to a more intimate family dinner where his daughter, Janay, played host while her wife served champagne and sparkling cider, keeping our glasses filled. Janay spoke to us all as if we were family.
It isn’t many dinner hosts who tell you deep intimate secrets like, “If I had a pet sugar glider, I would name it Gravy.”
Fate made it even more of a family simulacrum as the air conditioning went out during the meal. One of the strangers-cum-family, Dylan, was an A/C repairman, and before long the focus was able to return to Chef Jay’s master courses.
Before I tell you that this was the best turducken of my life, I must qualify this subjective opinion with the authority of family dinners in Louisiana. And while Chef Jay toned down the spice at the request of Janay for the sake of meeting the common denominators of the palates of strangers, it still was the best turducken of my life.
Chef Jay’s final secret pop-up dinner will be Christmas-themed in December. The date will be a secret for a few more days and the location a secret until the night before. The menu will be a secret until it lands in front of you.
The only way to experience this departing Central Florida legacy is to follow Table 410 on social media where ticket prices and details will be released.
The November Menu
Handmade pasta with butternut squash purée and gingered cranberry sauce
Seafood medley soup with fresh herbs and caramelized onions
Brussels sprout salad with smoked ham hock and balsamic glaze
Turducken with a duo of potatoes — sweet potatoes and roasted garlic mash — roasted carrots, and a citrus glaze
Cinnamon cake with pumpkin tres leches sauce, roasted pineapple, and shaved chocolate
Get a taste of Peruvian delight right here in Central Florida in our feature on Chabuca in Orlando.
Don’t Just Read It. Live It.
Get the latest stories, rankings, and culture from Pulp City delivered straight to your inbox.
Author
-
Adam Simon has won nine Best of Orlando awards for journalism, comic books, and other publications. He is on the Board of Directors for Orlando Youth Alliance. His TikTok channel (@TheManWhoTalks) has over 2M views. His novels (Psycho Babble, Black Dog, and Levi's In Africa) are available on Kindle. His lectures on practical application of applied artificial intelligence are available on YouTube (@ProfessorSimon). He is tied with Lance Armstrong for Tour De France wins and Time Magazine's 2006 Person of the Year.
English 






















































Paul Renner Takes the Long Road in His Run for Florida Governor
26th Dec 2025[…] Farewell Feast: Chef Jay’s Secret Supper Club Bids Orlando Goodbye […]